Consumer Reports lost a lot of credibility with me when they reviewed the XC40.
Link:
https://www.consumerreports.org/suvs/2019-volvo-xc40-suv-first-drive-review/
Their first beef with xc40 is a somewhat legit one, the "jerky" start-stop (now a moot point because you can turn it off ONE TIME and be done with it forever, and it makes a negligible impact on fuel economy).
Their second beef with xc40 is the gear shifter:
"Now, about that shifter: It's terrible. In order to engage Drive or Reverse, drivers need to move the gear selector twice in the appropriate direction, like a double-tap. If they miss the second tap, the transmission stays in Neutral. This can result in a delay during a parking maneuver and will surely frustrate drivers. Consumer Reports has repeatedly discussed the problems with these types of shifters in previous coverage. (Read "When It Comes to Automatic Shifters, It's Proceed With Caution.")
There are simply better ways to do this, and Volvo, particularly because it sees itself as the "safety" brand, should rethink this approach."
When I turn the car on, I press the power button, and then I "double-tap" the shifter to put it in reverse or drive. Done. It's simple, and there's nothing to it. There is no risk of "missing" the second tap, any more risk than there is missing a double-click on a mouse. Click it twice for double click. It's easy. And when I stop driving the car, I don't even touch it, I touch the Power button, that signals the transmission to shift into park, then it powers it down. I just don't get why CR makes such a huge deal of a feature that is so small. Is the shifter the best feature on the car? No. But it's unobtrusive and simple to use.
Their third problem is that the touch-screen involves too many swipes and taps and results in a lot of distracted driving:
"The other challenging feature is the XC40's central control screen. It looks inviting and high-tech, resembling a tablet computer, and serves as the command center for climate, audio, and phone controls. But using the system while driving is frustrating, thanks to the multiple taps, swipes, and scrolls necessitated to navigate through the layered menu structure."
This is just not true because the combination of Sensus Connect and CarPlay mean that a smart driver literally never has to touch the screen at all. For example:
"Set temperature 74" ... "Now set to 74 degrees."
"Set fan to max" ... "Fan is now set to max."
"Turn on steering wheel heat" etc etc
Apple CarPlay:
"Play popular songs by The Beatles." ... "Now playing The Beatles' popular songs."
"Play Imagine" .... "Now playing "Imagine by John Lennon."
"What's the weather?" "The weather is 84 degrees with showers this afternoon."
"Start directions home." "Starting directions home."
Bottom line: I almost never TOUCH the center screen let alone have it distracting me while I'm driving.