yea, it's a question of budget. Those START at $28k. For a guy like me with a family of four and an allergy to vans, I feel I'm doing ok with my Volvo. $5k to purchase a clean stage 0 V70R, then another $2k in the last year and a half in repairs, nothing half assed. Compared to $5k down for a new car and probably $4k a year in payments.
But there is no doubt a new car is generally better; a new "R Design" anything is likely to be faster than an old "R". You make a good point about longevity though. The 1999 Subaru I got out of at 155k was rusty, rattly and loud compared to the 1998 Volvo with 156k I got into. She was as trusty as she was rusty; however, the Volvo was nearly twice as expensive when new, and that echoes 14 years later.