My right front fender got hit when I was parked. That happened in February and my local body shop finally got around to doing the repair. He replaced the fender, painted it ... and even managed to match the orange peel. The lighting may play tricks with the color match on the photos, but the match is actually spot on. Since the fender was painted off the car, there's no way of telling it was ever replaced.
The guy is very good and he's done work for me before ... he's just very, very slow.