The dash and console trim was redesigned between 04 and 05. The pen holder isn't there for example. I don't remember if it leaves an ugly gap or not but it is not a direct swap. It splits by 01-04 and 05-10.
The gap that results from the swap isn't where the new shifter trim meets the climate control module (though the bottom of the ccm does hang out a little bit over the shifter trim), but there is a gap/groove around the gear selector. Apparently the 05+ gear selector must sit up higher than 01 - 04.
I've wondered if I could simply swap gear selectors as the R 05+ selectors look identical to the 01-04 selectors. Only noticeable difference is the W button has an S on it.
If you're looking to buy these bits in the very near future - I'm at the end of a manual swap. I will be posting my GT shift knob, GT shift bezel, and a brand new(still in its packaging) OEM Nordkap shift boot within the coming week. In case you want to call dibs on the set before I post them.